Chapter XVIII

1. ISSUES (BUDDHA) WORLD AND MANKIND (Manussaloka Katha)

Rate debate : Do not say: "The Buddha in the world of human life."

According to Note : This concept of sect  Vetulyakas , so the researchers do not carefully passages "... Born in the world, growing up in this world, shelter, conquer the world, not contaminated by world".They give birth Buddha in the Tushita Heaven and in realms that he was clean now and his life in the realms of humanity just as the current.

(1) Th: - But there must be no stupa, parks, synagogues, villages, cities, the land of the Buddha had been referring to?

(2) Is He not born in a garden Christmas  Lumbini , supreme enlightenment under the bodhi tree? Turn Falun in Benares? Is He not declared before the stupa died in  Chapala ? Does he not died in  Kusinara?

(3) Moreover, the Buddha once said: "Monks, where youth live it as hybrid Sala trees ... A childhood lived in it as hybrid Temple near Sravasti Member States ...".

Therefore, make sure that the living Buddha in the human world.

(4) V .: - But is Exalted: "Born in the human world, realized in the human world, living in the human world, but beyond the human world and not be contaminated in human world "?  (2)

Therefore, surely wrong to say: "Blessed to live in the human world."

2. ISSUES (BUDDHA) NOTES AND FRANCE(Dhammadesanakatha)

Rate debate : Do not say: "Blessed sermon itself."

According to Note : This concept of sect  Vetulyakas , said Buddha to Ānanda sermon in the world by being manifested, while he was still living in the realm of power confrontation.

(1) Th.- So who was the sermon?

V .: - Do Buddha manifested.

Th: - - So this has turned out to be to the level victory. Tier cardinal, Career Enlightenment, whole tri ranks and grades whole is, Omniscient, Secretarial Career tri turn, Article Dwell macho, Minh Hanh Additional etc ..

(2) Th: - I asked him again: Who is the sermon?

V .: - Venerable Ānanda.

Th: - Venerable Ānanda So also is the Awakened and grades.

(3) But does Buddha have urged that: "He Sariputta, As general theory lectures and special hybrid theory. As both hybrid theory: general and special theory of theory. This is only possible for the people themselves. .. "?  (1)

Therefore, make sure Buddha himself sermon.

(4) Again, there must have urged Buddha said: "Monks, with ultimate knowledge, as theory of the future can understand ..."?  (2)  . Therefore make sure that the Buddha himself preaching.

3. ISSUES (BUDDHA) AND compassion (Karunakatha)

Rate debate : Exalted no compassion.

According to Note : This concept of sect  Uttarapathakas , that compassion is a form of craving that Buddha had already craving annihilation should not have compassion.

(1) Th: - These imply that the Buddha is no kindness, sympathetic joy and equanimity. He refused.

(2) But can any 3 Blessed with this consciousness but lacks compassion?

(3) His argument This implies also that Blessed One, He has no pity to all beings, he agreed that the Buddha has compassion, death benefit, the lifetime health.

(4) Are Blessed Does not have compassion?

(5) U .: - But if Buddha did not have the heart of attachment  (raga)  to make sure that he did not have compassion  (Karuna)?

4. ISSUES (BUDDHA) AND excretion (Gandhajatikatha )

Rate debate : The quality of the Blessed excretion wins over all the other flavors.

According to Note : This concept of sect  Andhakas  and  Uttarapathakas.  This is the fanatical concepts of the Buddha.

(1) Th: - So he must imply that the Buddha only the aroma. But he also accepted Buddha eating, if so, the argument that he made inappropriate.

(2) Moreover, if his argument that rational, there is also a user ranking excreta of Buddha to stop, apply, store saved in boxes, in bags, bottles for sale in the market place as perfume, to makeup. But all this did not happen.

5. ISSUES UNIQUE Qingdao (Ekamaggakatha)

Rate debate : Four results are attained only by a Noble.

In Note : Many schools that Buddha into a Stream, Best hybrid, Real hybrid, Arhat, attaining four holy holy religion by a single.

(1) Th: - This implies that: There is a combination of four separate categories underwent heart of every church floor in the process of realization. This he refused. Moreover, if only a single direction, so how do directors coast for four results arise?

AU: - Arhat religion.

Th: - But did the first 3 months of the body is 10 afflictions, Sceptic, Gender prohibited by religion annihilation He was like this? Is Exalted has declared that 3 months is the total extinction by Path Project Save?

(2) And the courts have to rough and crude sexual desire must be total annihilation by Arhat religion?Is Exalted has declared Dao Nhat airport annihilation crude hybrids and crude sexual desire without remainder.

(3) And there must be directed Arhat whose afflictions are total annihilation? He knew that was not so.If he agrees I can cite for his teachings of Buddha, he has stated that: "It is no longer field any future raw and crude sexual desire".

(4) AU: - But if we're wrong, enlightened Buddha who directed one, how He called a Stream, hybrid Best Career, Career Real hybrid tier Arhat reasonable? He refused, but his arguments did imply this?

(5) Th: - If all 4 Blessed Fruit detailed evidence by a unique Noble and His disciples to realize 4 by 4 direct result, the disciples he saw that the German legal world religion does not see, is the legal enlightenment of the Buddha is not enlightened. He could not accept this ...

6. THE TRANSITION ISSUES IN MEDITATION CLASS(Jhanasankantikatha)

Rate debate : We attained this meditation floor to floor another meditation (immediately).

According to Note : This concept of sect  Mahimsasakas  and  Andhakas  that progress attained from floor to floor Zen meditation is no intermediate stage.

(1) Th: - Does this imply that: A practitioner of Zen meditation to triangle, from the quarter-second meditation to meditation? He rejected ...

(2) Or take the attainment of meditation to attain the second meditation. He confirmed that article may occur. He implied that in the process of intentional consciousness, the desire, the idea in mind, the focus of meditation ... just as demand for attaining the second meditation, the attention, the expectations, the the second meditation focus. He disagrees. Does he think that no mental process of attention, expectations, ... the need for meditation binary stars: However, he agreed that the second meditation arise after certain mental processes, attention, the desire ... Therefore, a practitioner can not attain directly from Zen meditation to the higher floors.

(3) (Again, grab objects and properties of meditation). In meditation He admitted that it is a state of blissful, because sexual ly birth, with views and extremities. But the objects and properties, he must admit that is not in the second meditation. However, his opinion really make him have to admit there is a distinction between meditation and Zen II.

(4) Arguments similar to (2) is applied in the second meditation and meditation triangle.

(5) (Again, grab objects and properties in the Second Jhana). He admits that the wedding is a state second meditation, being very optimistic due to reach the quarterfinals property. But he had to admit in the triangle of meditation without these characteristics. However, his opinion really make him have to accept there is a subtle distinction between meditation and meditation triangle.

(6) (reasoning similar to (2) and (4) is applied to the triangle of meditation and meditation quartet).

(7) (Again, grab objects and characteristics of the triangle of meditation). He admitted, tam meditation is resident status communal joy, mindfulness and awareness, feel the pleasures themselves. But the object and this feature is not in charity. His view, however, really makes him to accept the distinction between the three meditation and charity.

(8) MA: - But did the Buddha have urged that: "Monks, any monks in this law and, cup education, legal ly ... evil evil primary residence certificate Tu Zen meditation ... "?  (1)

Therefore, a yogi can go from Zen meditation levels to another level without any intermediate stage.

7. ISSUES MEDITATION - Meditation interruption (Jhanantarika Katha)

Rate debate : There is an interruption between meditation and Zen II.

According to Note : This concept of sect  Sammitiyas  and  Andhakas , said that in five places of meditation, the Buddha did not advocate classification that indicates there are three types of claim: Concentration Organic Organic Games quarterfinals, the property wealth Games quarterfinals, and the multitude carefree mind. Therefore, there is an interruption between meditation (Friendly Friends Games quarterfinals) and the Two meditation (Unknown reach quarterfinals property).

(1) Th: - But this implies that there is also an interruption between the contact, feeling great, Tu ....

(2) Again, why there is no interruption between the third second meditation and meditation, or between triangle and quad Zen meditation? If he rejected the disruption here, he must also reject the interruption between meditation and Zen II.

(3) He could not maintain only interruption between meditation and Zen II.

(4) That the refusal of uninterrupted meditation floors.

(5) He says Concentration meditation is very useful range quarterfinals indirect ownership. But why is there an exception in this case? Why not include two other forms related to both (Concentration Organic Organic quartet range) or is unrelated to both (spouses and impartial views)

(6) If He rejected both organic range Dinh Dinh Organic Quartet and Quartet countless vain meditation indirect ownership, why does not he have rejected meditation indirect ownership in property cases reach quarterfinals Concentration wealth?

(7) He maintains that there is no range Concentration Organic Quartet, the two-storey Zen meditation indirect ownership. But while Dinh such as continuous process. Is no meditation ended the second meditation on the star born? He agreed, but because he was so contradictory to the point that he made.

(8) SM: - If we're wrong, there must be no range Concentration Organic quartet forming any one of the four jhaanas reasonable? He does not agree? Then it must constitute indirect ownership meditation, this is what we have confirmation.

(9) Th: - But is Exalted has declared with 3 types of: It is useful range Dinh Dinh myriad range organic and organic quartet quartet and an impartial Games?  (1)   If so, he can not yet merely said: Concentration meditation is very useful range quarterfinals indirect ownership between floors meditation.

MEDITATION AND ISSUES 8. Canh Thinh (Samapanno Saddam Sunatitikatha)

Rate debate : Tier enter meditation can hear the silent scene.

According to Note : This concept of sect  Pubbaseliyas . As the Buddha said that the silence of meditation obstacles, and if not heard, the silence can not be an obstacle for entering the meditation practitioner, so regardless of Zen meditators can hear sound.

(1) Th: - If so, then he has to accept the same level as imported meditation can see by the label color, smell incense billion, tasted and touched by bodily injury? This He refused ... He would have to admit that the entry level of meditation, meditation attained consciousness enjoys the scene. He rejected, did he agree to arise when a person is to know how the legal situation?

(2) If She consents anyone enjoying scene and thinh by listening tiếng is cetasika specify from enjoying scene so. He will not accept that a person is in the state that is heard. If He emphasized this level could hear, then at him, he has two parallel mental processes simultaneously.

(3) P. - But did the Buddha have urged that: "Silence is the obstacle for meditation." So surely that import levels meditation can hear

Th: - He said that import levels and meditation can hear the language of the Buddha needle cited: "In silent meditation there is the obstacle". Further, we can say that the range and an obstacle to the quarter-second meditation. Does meditation have a range of quad rank affordable entry? "Again, the wedding is the third obstacle meditation. Breath of jhana is hindrance, an obstacle excellent idea of ​​boundless cents, the obstacle of the infinitude of consciousness ..." Obstacles which also present in the attainment of meditation when it is called to be an obstacle? If you do not like how he can call the obstacle of silence still exists for practitioners of meditation?

9. character issues IDENTITY AND PERSPECTIVES(Cakkhunarupampassatitikatha)

Rate debate : We see objects with labels scenery.

According to Note : This concept of sect  Mahasanghikas , based on the teachings of the Buddha, "When one sees eye color", they think of eye color visible nerves. In fact, within the meaning of the Buddha's discourses, is understood to be seen by consciousness.

(1) Th: - Well, he said that we see the color by color (nervous) ... He denies it. But think again! And if now, he agreed. He implies that the identity can distinguish colors. He refused, but think again? And if now he agrees, he implies that identity is the identity.

(2) Again, he implies that the label material can note the determination ... Although he agrees the opposite is rational.

(3-4) The same argument like that for four other official (ear, nose, tongue, body).

(5) M .: - But did the Buddha have urged that: "Monks here, monks saw sharp eye, hear with atrial ..." (1)   So, definitely that we see eye scenery.

-ooOoo-

CHAPTER XIX

1. ISSUES stroll negativity (Kilesajahanakatha)

Rate debate : Can we make an end to the troubles past, future, present.

In Note : Because there is a law such as the cessation negativity towards a fully enlightened level has in the past, future and present, should send  Uttarapathakas  for that now, we can make an end to the troubling past brain.

(1) Th: - In other words, we can do to stop the killing was legal, the legal disarmament has disintegrated, the legal destruction have been destroyed, the completion of measures already completed, apply delete the law has been applied to remove. Does past not perish? Does the past still exists reasonable?

(2) Likewise for the future, he implies that we can make the law and will not be born again and born for the non-existent legal past, as the law also engenders sleep implicit. Thus there is no future to birth? Does the future still exists?

(3) Likewise for the present, there must be people who have been craving craving annihilation, the hatred is hatred annihilation, the delusion is ignorance annihilation, the negativity is negativity annihilation ? Or we can make an end is by the craving craving, hatred is total annihilation by the anger it? He denies all this. But does he not accept that, we can make an end to the current negativity?

"Is craving and religion as factors in the process of the mind? Of course he agreed, but there can be no parallel in the two types of consciousness at once? If the craving is immoral and religion is moral consciousness, there can any good and evil methods, measures and legal guilt of innocent, law and legal lowly noble, pollution and legal measures in the existing clean once? He rejected. think back. Now he meeting agreed.

And there must have urged Buddha said: "Monks, there are four very far apart. What four? Heaven and earth, the sea shore and the other side of the sea, the sunrise and the face sunset, measures of good and evil people ... "Thus the conflicting law can not exist in the same time.

(4) U: - But if the mistake of saying, "We could make an end to the troubles past, present and future", there is no legal right to make an end is no negativity or what? He admitted that there was legal.Therefore our perspective given stand.

2. ISSUES EMPTINESS (Sunnatakatha)

Rate debate : "The empty" included in operating aggregates ( Sankhara - kkhandha) .

According to the commentary:  "The emptiness" has 2 meanings: (a) there is no self, but merely the existence of the five aggregates (nama and rupa). For this sense, some of the reviews on "No-self" is included in operating aggregates regulatory language. (b) Nirvana. But since there are two significant distinction should sect  Andhakas  had conceived on.

(1) Th: - If such a concept, he said that measures have "no evidence" and legal "civil Africa" (1)   is also included in the formations. Otherwise the law "Void" can not be included in the aggregate is.

(2) He could not identify the latter case, "Void" while rejecting the first two cases (Unknown internal controls and Africa).

(3) Again, if the formations related to "Empty", then it is not a legal non impermanence, non-compounded, mutual non-medical, non-ly compassionate, non-eradicated, non-mutated!.

(4) Moreover, there must be "emptiness" of the aggregate of form is also included in the formations?Or "emptiness" of sensations, ideas aggregates, consciousness, is also included in the formations? Or does "The emptiness" of volitional itself included in any public aggregates?

(5) If there is one conclusion to be false, then all the other wrong conclusions.

(6) But is Exalted have urged that "Monks, this is the emptiness is the practice, the self or what belongs to the self"?  (2)

3. ISSUES achievement (Samannaphalakatha)

Rate debate : Sainthood is unconditioned.

In Note : Sports Dharma, "the noble fruit" means fruit-process arises from religion. But the sect Pubbaseliyas,  again understand the problem in a different direction, they think "fruits of the holy religion" arises when annihilation negativity, without charming, without preparation, without artificial by four things event: now, the mind, as the food and the yin-yang.

(1) Th: - If such a concept, is identified with the result that nirvana: the secret, the clinic, is immortal?Or are there two unconditioned? He rejected both issues (but to agree to one of two issues). If for the latter, I asked him: are both Nirvana ... with the high and the low, the boundaries between them?

(2) Again, did he imply that the celibate life is itself unconditioned not? He replied, "As compounded."Therefore there must result was "unconditioned"?

(3) Again, he admitted that, 4 or 4 floors holy religion is compounded. But he still refused result of compounded 4.

(4) In fact, he said, 4 and 5 unconditioned Nirvana. Or, if this result Him regulatory 4 with Nirvana, he must show that there are 5 types of Nirvana, 5 immortal ...

4. REALIZATION PROBLEMS (Pattikatha)

Rate debate : The realization is unconditioned.

According to Note : This concept of sect  Pubbaseliyas , said any evidence per se it is also unconditioned

(1) Arguments similar to section (1).

(2-4), Th: - Again does he imply that: The gain (by the way alms) clothes, bowls, cushions, medication treatment is also invisible because why? If that would have the same dilemma as in the case appeared in general attained. In fact, he had said, 4 and Nirvana is unconditioned.

(5-6) The same argument applies to gender identity or 4 4 Zen meditation formless or 4 direct and 4 eggs. He should also say that 4 directors, 4 eggs and 4 of 9 unconditioned Nirvana.

(7) P .: - But if I'm wrong, he can do the attainment designation, with any aggregates in five aggregates, or the identity of the list? If not, the attainment of that is unconditioned.

5. ISSUES Brackets (Tathatakatha)

Rate debate : The fundamental characteristics of all measures is unconditioned.

According to Note : This concept of sect  Uttarapathakas , said an immutable law called Brackets (or First imperialism) in all measures. And so choose to not cover compounded itself should be unconditioned.

(1) Th: - Do you agree that the characteristics of the platform or "docking" with Nirvana ... Immortality? Or are there two types of unconditioned? He rejects both this (which he would have to accept either). For the latter case, I asked whether he would have two types of immortality? And there must be boundaries ... or the division between them?

(2) Again, assuming the case of hard material or physical nature, there is not material to the unconditioned? He agreed. so I will make such unsolvable.

(3) If he accepts the success of life, the success of the concept, the success of the practice and the success of the formula, if all these measures are unconditioned, so there must have 6 types of unconditioned not?

(4) U .: - But if I'm wrong, then there must Brackets of all 5 aggregates legal?

Th: - Well, yes.

U .: - If so, then by all legal Brackets is unconditioned.

6. GENDER ISSUES Nirvana (Kusalakatha)

Rate debate : good legal Nirvana's world.

According to Note : All good mental state is so called because they are immaculate, providing results endearing ability immaculate wedding or exiting the negativity. The idea of the immaculate be applied to all but also immoral wedding shirt fairly well affect the regeneration in the future and the immaculate in 3 parts: positive, negative and neutral is the cause for birth such fruit. But the sect Andhakas  not get this distinction should assume that Nirvana is good because it's in immaculate condition.

(1) Th: - Does he imply that nirvana is also the legal world scene also know as the mental processes a great memory, attention ... the determination? Are the opposite is rational?

(2) These measures, which can be identified as good as alobha law, no courts, intelligence, signals, need, mindfulness, concentration and wisdom. But if we can not identify such measures to Nirvana, Nirvana, the world can not be called a good approach.

(3) A .: - But is not immaculate gender nirvana? If so, as he has acknowledged. It is not immoral law, so the law is good.

7. ISSUES AND by- laws of NATURE (Accantaniyamakatha)

Rate debate : ordinary people can have a certain destiny.

According to Note : This concept of sect  Uttarapathakas , due out passages from "A person with a pensive and sink" should have this notion.

(1) Th: - ordinary He said that there is a certain destiny even if this person committed the crime as college ranks against patricide, matricide, killing Arhat, Buddha bleeding, increased harmony break ?He disagrees. again, any ordinary person can be skeptical about this certain destiny? He agreed, so ordinary people can not be certain sensations.

(2) He certainly agree that if ordinary people have certain feelings, they can not be skeptical about the sensations are. Ordinary person can not make an end to skepticism? He said no? But think again!

Now, he agreed. Such ordinary person to make an end to skepticism directed by a Stream reasonable?Best hybrid religion? Any future direction? or Arhat religion?

U .: - By directing immoral.

Th: - Does he want to say that evil religion brought to truth, lead to the total extinction of greed, hatred and delusion, leading to the realization, leading to the escape afflictions, brought to purity? Does not evil opposite direction with all this ...?

(3) The piece is conceived and becomes addicted to accept this concept, there is generally believed in it or not? He said yes. Then surely ordinary person in trust for their passage is not there a certain absolute determinism.

(4) Now if he rejects my answer questions, and I will repeat the question again, ordinary person to make an end is conceived piece is reasonable? If so, the notion that there was annihilation by 4 faith?He answered as before by directing immoral. This also means: by evil religion that ordinary person has to make an end is immoral views.

(5-6) The same argument in the case is to make an end is to the segment often is.

(7) U .: - If I'm wrong, there must be Exalted have urged that "Monks, who in this life in union with black and immoral law, then they are also their own muses and sink "  (1)  ? Therefore, any ordinary person can also certain fate.

(8) Th: - Does He cited as reasons to maintain the point that he made? He accepted. Moreover, Buddha has also been theories that "Monks, there are people in this world rose and sank again"? Did this event happen for a while? of course not.

(9) Again, the Buddha also had presentations: "Monks, someone sank then outcrops, coral firmly grip the body, identify and looked around with effort, he waded across the river, with the guy they are trying to rip currents and swim to shore. " Are all beings always act like that all the time? and whether any case, he also said that "any ordinary person has a certain destiny"?

8. RIGHTS ISSUES NGU (Indriyakatha)

Rate debate : Five good right: Tin, Can, mindfulness, concentration and wisdom is not in the mundane measures.

According to Note : This view of the sect  Hetavadins  and  Mahimsasakas.

(1) Th: - Does he imply that: There can be no credit, needs, thoughts, intellectual property related to the mundane law? He declined.

(2) On the other hand, he maintains that: There credits, related to legal attack ... but not half as good rights.

(3) He accepts both standard and the legal rights related to the mundane. And he also accepted similar with both joy and rapture right, both the network and the network right.

(4) Why is the right to exclude 5?

(5) Again, he admits the believers, and believers right. Why are not both believers and believers mundane mundane right? Likewise for the wedding and the wedding rights.

(6) Why accept a case to reject other cases?

(7) Moreover, there must be Exalted have urged that "Bhikshus with pure divine eye, we see all superhuman beings, there are fewer classes dust, dust with more classes, with class the right to grow old, young right-class. Having good grades, have bad grades, can easily show enlightened classes, hard-class show enlightened ... "  (1)   Therefore, make sure 5 rights related to union law card.

-ooOoo-

Chapter XX

1. INCIDENTAL sin problem (Asanciccakatha)

Rate debate : Five great against crime, even if there is no intent, no cockroaches also reborn in hell after death.

According to Note : This concept of sect  Uttarapathakas.

(1) Th: - But he said that if I accidentally killing, I was a murderer.

(2) And (similarly for the evil deed). If I do not inadvertently grab the thief, I was ... If I accidentally say it's not, then I'm Liars. Who refused. But he excluded for higher ranks against crime.

(3) Is it possible that he cited me a prayer about the unintentional offense, such as "A person who unintentionally killed his mother, the college suffered five grave offenses"? He could not be documented. Then, he could not sustain his argument that offer.

(4) U: - But is not the phenomenon of the mother is still alive after being killed? Thus, the murderer inadvertently also be punished in hell no cockroaches.

(5-7) Similarly, for people who accidentally killed his father, killed level Arhat, shedding the blood of Buddha, also under penalty like that.

(8) Th: - For offenses dealt Sangha harmony with Him must believe that all the harmony break now increases are subject to numerous cockroaches? He declined. But think again, and he agreed. And there must be a harmonious Sangha break a lawful manner, there are now countless cockroaches do not create? He refused. But think again! He agreed. And there must be Exalted have urged that "Hey Upali, fruits harmony broke punished increase suffering in hell, not in this world suffer the penalty,"  (1) ?Therefore, it is not justified to say that the increased clearance in accordance with the legal harmony, with a true heart will be reborn countless cockroaches.

(9) U: - But is Exalted also have urged that "the break will be subject to increased integration into woeful, reborn in hell eons always a"  (2) ? Therefore, make sure that the increase will have to destroy the harmony of punishment in hell after death.

2. PROPERTY ISSUES AND byproducts (Nanakatha)

Rate Debate:  Tue not available to ordinary people.

In Note:  Tue ( Nana ) there are 2 types: human wisdom and holy wisdom. All that wisdom involves many different attainment, even holy Paths and IP-related or related to the performance analysis of the Four Great. Phai  Hetuvadins  did not distinguish between these two skill, only to admit a new religion called intellectual knowledge and so they deny ordinary people with insight.

(1) Th: - But he implied that the ordinary person has no discrimination, no intellectual understanding, no research, no choice ... no scout law, no wisdom results. There is the opposite of sense?

(2) Again, did he accept? Ordinary people can not enter or gender identity Zen meditation formless, not attained, or incapable of generosity from the widgets? Therefore, make sure that is not justified to say that the ordinary person has no insight.

(3) H .: - if ordinary people have knowledge, did people have wisdom to know suffering, but is disabled, and developing clear guidance kill reasonable? He acknowledged no intellectual ordinary person there. Offal....

3. ISSUES Pluto (Nirayapatakatha)

Rate Debate:  In hell no Pluto.

According to Note:  This concept of sect  Andhakas , for that no such beings.

(1) Th: - Is He said that no punishment in hell? He has to maintain the opposite view? But he could not maintain the second argument is.

(2) Is He accepted in the earth, and there are penalties, but the executioner? But he still refused Pluto existing king in hell ...

(3) Moreover, there must be Exalted have urged that "Whatever does not kill all the legal steps to be Princess preta, not kill King Moon, Pluto, multicultural heavenly king, do not kill other people's business ... "? Therefore Pluto in hell.

(4) Moreover, there have also been Exalted theory that "Monks, the middle of hell Valet, force it to accept the punishment called 5 poles, we get close to the red-hot iron stake a hand , close to the 2nd hands, close to the first foot, close to the 2nd foot, close to the center of the chest. here he feels miserable life leader, fierce anguish. But it can not be shared destiny until its grim yet to be eliminated "?  (1)

(5) Again, there must be Exalted have urged that "Monks, holder of hell, and built up the first leg beneath it and grab hammers ... the hell Valet keep its columns in a vehicle, pull it back and forth on the ground running, was burning red, flaming, red fire ... then the monks, where he cooked with boiling water bubbles, when they rise above, when it sank to the bottom. when the cross ... then this drift monks, who regarded kept throwing it into the great hell of hell "?  (1)   Therefore, certainly in Hades hell.

4. HAVING PROBLEMS BANG (Piracchana Katha)

Rate Debate:  The animal still exists in the realm of gods.

According to Note:  In the realm of gods, many shaped like animalzxy as  Eravana ; shaped like elephants or horses, but no species animalzxy rebirth in this realm. But the sect  Andhakas , back to that on earth gods, there's rebirth animalzxy species.

(1) Th: - Is He also conceived the opposite is reborn gods in animalzxy species? or is the world's gods animalzxy world? locusts, grasshoppers, flies, mosquitoes, snakes, scorpions still in the realms of gods reasonable? He rejected all these things. Therefore, he could not maintain his thesis that make ...

(2) A .: - But there must have elephants  Eravana  in the realm gods are thousands of cars pulled over his realm?

(3) Sat .: - But in the realm of gods must also have horses, with grooms, with elephant trainer reasonable? ...

5. ISSUES Qingdao (Maggakatha)

Rate debate : Noble only 5 chi.

According to Note : This concept of sect  Mahimsasakas , said that the path of common sense only 5 chi. They understand the issues from the passage "A person who is completely pure ..." do not need to have three chi Right Speech. Right Action, Right Livelihood because these three is not like 5 mentality residual limb.

(1) Th: - But did the Buddha has declared that there is 8 directing the Right, Right Thought, Right Speech, Right Action, Right Livelihood, Right Effort, Right Mindfulness and Right Concentration.

(2) And does he also have urged that "in all the way, the Noble Eightfold Path is paramount. In all truth. From Empire to the ultimate. In all things, sex is the ultimate cup . In all mankind Blessed is the ultimate level "  (1)   so religion certainly has 8 limbs.

(3) But he told me that 3 chi direction: Right Speech, Right Action, Right Livelihood is although they are not directing the director.

(4) While in the other direction just as religion is both direct expenditures. Why this distinction?

(5) M .: - But did the Buddha have urged that "Those who with purity of industry body, speech and network chief he will develop the Eightfold Path"? Therefore, make sure that there are 5 chi religion.

(6) Th: - But did the Buddha have urged that "Hey Subhada, the path with 8 limbs, can not have the law and the other, though ... well no ... monk Sa 2nd half ... Sa Sa .... 3rd goal 4th goal, but only within the law and this new Noble Eightfold path and the monk "  (2) ? Therefore, make sure that the Path with 8 limbs.

6. PROPERTY ISSUES (Nanakatha)

Rate debate : Tue 12 Tue part does.

According to Note : This concept of law  Pubhaseliyas , involved 12 sections in all of Zhuan Falun.

(1) Th .: - Is He said that there are 12 types of knowledge? He declined. I repeat the question, He accepted. So there must have 12 kinds of knowledge of a Stream Path? The Fruits of Wisdom's 12 saved? ... And 12 other fruits Wisdom of Truth? ...

(2) P.:- But does Buddha have urged that:

- (I) This is the Noble Truth of Suffering, the monks and monks, for the law had never been heard before, arises to as hybrid vision, the knowledge, wisdom, insight knowledge and light. (Ii) Noble Truths to be aware; (Iii) Noble Truths are aware;

- (I) This is Episode Truths of Suffering; (Ii) Class Noble Truths to be aware of (iii) Noble Truths Volume was aware;

- (I) This is the Cessation of Suffering Truths; (Ii) Cessation of Suffering Truths to be realized;(Iii) Cessation of Suffering Truths have been realized;

- (I) This is the Cessation of Suffering Truths Path; (ii) Cessation of Suffering Truths Path should be developed; (iii) Cessation of Suffering Truths Path has been developed "?  (3)

Therefore, section 12 is Tue Tue superpower.

-ooOoo-

CHAPTER XXI

1. ISSUES DHARMA (Sasanakatha)

Rate debate : our dharma can be modified.

In Note : Because after the Tripitaka compiled the third time, seconded  Uttarapathakas  teachings that can be modified, this problem arises who has the ability to modify the teaching and the law can be corrected team.

(1) Th .: - These methods can be modified? Chief quarterfinals need? Quartet as the sufficiency? Five right? Five forces, Interior enlightenment? Or amending measures can improve the unwholesome? It is illegal Or, Trien, blessed, ... Negativity is changed to non-pirated ... non negativity? He rejected all these things: But the argument he made to involve one of those things.

(2) Or as he said that any person may also be amended by the Buddha Dharma has found? If this is so in this teaching, public law is amended? He refused ...

(3) If He said that the teachings can be modified. So he accepted what legal amendments in the teachings of the Tathāgata?

2. The issue of NOW (Avirittathakatha)

Rate debate : ordinary people can not escape the industry in the third world.

In Note : According to the Explanatory Note, a person at a time can identify phenomena existing nomenclature right at that time.

(1) Th.- He implies that ordinary people still inseparable Promotion, Feeling, Perception, Will, Games, Tin Can, mindfulness, concentration and wisdom belong to three realms? He refused. But he can explain more about the legal alternative to above?

(2) Again, he implies that when a person giving clothes, cushions, medication treatment, in that moment he is not the person's mind, but also giving excellent meditation and formless world great.

(3) Delegation of the opposition: - But ordinary person must have the ability to distinguish what led them now reborn gender identity or formless? If not, then make sure that the ordinary person can not be broken with the lead now reborn in all three realms.

3. ISSUES Trade (Sannojanakatha)

Rate debate : Enlightenment Arhat without hindrances annihilation.

In Note : Gender  Mahasanghikas  with this concept in terms of ignorance and skepticism slopes slopes, said oil is an Arhat does not know Wisdom of the Buddhas.

(1) Th: - Does he imply that enlightened Arhat body is not required to make an end, Sceptic, the first precept, Love, hatred and delusion, expensive room? He refused. Therefore, given the views he could not maintain.

(2) Or does he imply that the Arhat level is still love, hatred, ignorance, conceit ... Are the facts of this level is the opposite? Therefore, how can he say that there are still hindrances that level Arhat is not annihilation?

(3) M .: - If I'm wrong, there must be a level Arhat with pure enlightenment of a Buddha knows reasonable? He agrees that he can not know. Therefore, I am very rational.

4. ISSUES THAN INFORMATION (Iddbikatha)

Rate debate : Buddha and his disciples supreme clairvoyance to manifest what He wants.

According to Note : This concept of sect  Andhakas .

(1) Th: - Does he imply that the Buddha or a disciple can make those wishes be fulfilled, such as trees forever green, blossom forever, forever for results; Moon forever immortal ...?

(2) Or is desirable "Please do not contact arisen to destroy, applying for sensation, perception has arisen .... not to kill"?

(3) Or is desirable "Please give this body, this mind becomes everlasting"

(4) Or desire "All beings, birth, aging, sickness and death do not birth, not old, not sick, not dead." All these things he refused. so, what is his point?

(5) A .: - If I'm wrong, there must Venerable Pilindavaccha prayed that "May the palace of the King led into gold and gold palace was the truth"? ...

5. ISSUES Buddhas (Buddhakatha)

Rate debate : different Buddhas of proficiency.

According to Note : We view that, except for differences in appearance, longevity, at any time whatsoever, Buddhas no differences in other aspects. However, some sects like  Andhakas , has said that he has different abilities.

This concept of sect  Andhakas .

(1) Th .: - If such a concept, is the difference in his enlightenment? about magic powers? About omniscient knowledge? the label Property? ...

6. MARKET ISSUES OF BUDDHIST PRACTICE TEN (Sabbadisa Katha)

Rate debate : seated Buddhas in all directions. Buddhas have manifested 10 attacks.

According to Note : Some sects like  Mahasanghikas  that a Buddha dwells in all directions. He can change the form to go into the realm.

(1) Th .: - Are seated Buddhas He said that in the East? He refused, so he was self-contradictory. He agreed. I ask Him in the east, the Buddha spent his nickname? His family like? What clan? Name of parents, name of the two disciples? Name of Buddha attendant was dressed and carrying bowls like?Him in any village, any province, any kingdom, what country?

(2) Does the Buddha seated in the north, south, west, above, below, under the direction? (With questions like the above). Or is he comes in the Four Deva Kings? Path beneficial? Da ma? Where productivity? Corrupts himself in? ... Brahma World? If he agrees, I would ask him to add more points ...

LEGAL ISSUES 7. (Dhammakatha)

Rate debate : All natural law is not changed

According to Note : This concept of two sectarian  Andhaka s and  Uttarapathakas  because they do not distinguish between natural evil  (micchattaniya)  and chief of course ( sammatta niyata ).

(1) Th .: - Is He said that all depends on the legal order of the evil as certain people will be reborn in hell no cockroaches or enlightened person will succeed ultimate liberation? Is not there a 3rd case? He refused, but think again. Definitely yes, right? He agreed. Therefore, he was self-contradictory to the point that he made.

(2) And he must accept that, because there must be Exalted has declared that the three measures that or what? (France misconduct for certain results after the next life, the legal chief for consecutive balls moment, and legal uncertainty for both)

(3) He admits that material designated as identity and identity? (Or a certain aggregates) is designated as a list? So in addition to the two cases, the law in cases specified 3rd like?

(4) AU: - But if I can not say that the identity or the identity specified list or list, then would become the name of excellence, could yet become one of the four mental aggregates, or vice versa? Of course not? So, certainly I'm very rational.

8. ISSUES NOW (Kamma Katha)

Rate debate : All is fixed now (no change).

According to Note : This view of the two sects  Andhakas  and  Uttarapathakas  because they do not distinguish between natural evil  (micchata niyata)  and chief of course ( sammatta niyata).

(1) Theory 1 and 2 above.

(3) Sat .: - He said that now occur in the event of life is fixed. He agreed. so there must now depend on a certain natural laws? He refused. It does not belong to a certain law is. Likewise for the fruit industry - is now, post-industrial, post-industrial post.

(4) AU: - But cophai He admits that there is no type of any of the three types of business now may be changed to two different types of business? Thus, our notions of how wrong?

-ooOoo-

Chapter XXII 

1. ISSUES fullness of holy life (Paranibbanakatha)

Rate debate : A holy life does not need to be perfect and make an end to the slopes.

According to Note : This notion of sectarian  Andhakas.

(Reasoning as XXI. 3)

2. ETHICAL ISSUES FOCUS (Kusalacittakatha)

Rate debate : Tier Arhat before he died there of moral consciousness.

According to Note : This notion of sectarian  Andhakas .

(1) Th: - He implies that: A Career Arhat merit still operating, estate executive, is still creating interesting now to go to the instruction, still born, but created the large property and has the backing of the gods or the human realm.

(2) He implies that: A Career Arhat still accept his passing and letting go, freed or clinging, contained or bound, still hoarding or collecting. For an Arhat a complete liberation of people who can do that he is still clinging, bound not?

3. REAL ISSUES OF FOCUS (Anenjakatha)

Rate debate : Tier Arhat existing entirely in estate operating status.

According to Note : This concept of sect  Uttarapathakas.

(1) Th.- But there must rank Arhat no mental well-stars? He agreed that there. So, how he can solve this in his main argument given?

(2) He implied Arhat level when the center passed away happy. Did not mind the result?

(3) Whether He said Arhat level when the heart neutral passed away happy, but I still believe that neutral mind work?

(4) Are Blessed Charity out and, thereafter, passed away it?

4. MYTH words to common problems (Phanunablusamayakatha)

Rate debate  : beings in the womb still has the potential to realize soles quarterfinals.

According to Note : This concept of sect  Uttarapathakas , said a person was born before a Stream should be able to realize in the womb soles quarterfinals

(1) Th: - He implies that the being in the womb can lecture, listeners law, capable vow world, capable of completion ... is not the opposite true?

(2) There must be no affinity to arise as silent right view of others and as of volition?

(3) And can any one person is sleeping, be neglectful, forgetfulness, not vigilant and well enlightened Emperor Quartet?

5. REALIZATION PROBLEMS (Tissopikatha)

Rate debate : There are 3 cases:

- Realizing Arhat in the womb.
- Four Truths Enlightenment dream with people.
- Realization Arhat with people dream.

In Note : Since there are cases attained Arhat son layman Suppayasa as he was seven years old, so some schools have this concept. All three cases above reasoning (XXII. 4)

6. LEGAL ISSUES neutral (Abyakatakatha)

Rate debate : All dreams are the mind neutral.

According to Note : This concept of sect  Uttarapathakas.

(1) Th.- Is He acknowledged that people might see their dreams are guilty of killing, stealing ...? So how can he call this center is to be neutral?

(2) U: - If I'm wrong, did Buddha once said that the dream consciousness is negligible (because no attention)?

And if so, given my thesis can stand.

7. PROBLEMS FIXED EFFECTS COAST (Asevanapaccayakatha)

Rate debate : No incidents charming effect.

According to Note : This concept of sect  Uttarapathakas.

(1) Th.- But does Buddha have urged that "Hey monks, killing is done, is to practice, made for fullness, leading to hell, leading to animalzxy species, put to the hungry ghost realm. Fruits mature very mild allergic  (sabbalahuse) , the killing is made of people with a short life span. "

(2) Again, "Hey monks, taking what is not to be done ... ghosts. Fruit maturity very mild horror of people do not get to the property damage. Hey monks, sexual misconduct in the preta is done .... the fruit mature very mild horror of sexual misconduct is made in person to the hatred of the enemy. this, monks, lying is done .. . preta. Fruits mature very mild horror of lying is made accused person is not true. this, brethren. said two blades are made, ... ghosts. the fruit is extremely mild allergic said two blades are made with friends who have broken up. this evil monks say export is done ... ghosts. Fruit maturity downright horror of saying harsh light that made people to be heard is not available reviews. Behold the monks say frivolous is done .... Peta. Fruits mature heterosexual say downright frivolous light is made of people with hearing the words difficult to accept. Behold monks, drink yeast, cooking wine, is made ... ghosts. Fruit maturity very mild horror of drinking alcohol is cooked with heart made people mad "?  (1)

TIME MONITORING ISSUES 8. NA (Khanikakatha )

Rate debate : All measures exist only in a moment.

According to Note : This view of the sect  Pubbaseliyas  and  Aparaseliyas,  that all are impermanent, they only exist in one mind moment.

(1) Th: - Does he imply that: Mountains, sea, mountain, Tudi, water, fire, wind, trees, forests, all of which exist in the mind? He refused ...

(2) Or, Does he imply that the origin mark with the consciousness that arises in the mind is not the same moment? If he agrees, I would like to remind him that the German legal relics declared that "reverence, the label is not consumed within the law, but is a legal identity to the outside yet, there is no coordination, harmony, the presentation of the official out no, and if the label is not consumed within the law ... Turkish origin, originating Rate, Damage Made, Made Body. "  (1)   So, based on where that He could define your concept?

(3) similar discourse about 4 ways: ear, nose, tongue, body.

(4) PA: - But is all ... not legal permanent change?

Th: - no, can not say so.

-ooOoo-

Chapter XXIII

1. DELIVERY OF PRAYER ISSUES (Ekadhippayokatha)

Rate debate : The sexual contact may begin with a desire to associate words  (Ekadhippayo).

In Note : Gender  Andhakas  and  Vetulyakas  said such a prayer is determined by two people with emotional or mutual pity (not merely sexual) they have vowed before Buddha statues and desire to during delivery of a next life. Actually, there is no objection to the relationship was initiated so, except for the monk or monks of the Sangha.

(1) Th .: - Is He implies that a desire to associate words can be decided so. Not worthy of a monk, not become monks, or that it can be determined by a person who has been the source of annihilation rebirth, or when there is an association will lead public office to any crime?

Or when there is an association, can be guilty of defamation as: expectations discourse, bisexual damage, theft, adultery ...?

(He must be a clearer distinction in the wording "by a desire to associate words")

2. ISSUES OF negotiations with North Arhat false(Arahanlavannakatha)

Rate debate : Customers can inhuman level prostitution with "Arhat".

According to Note : This concept of sect  Uttarapathakas -  The reason for this perception because the title Arhat is used incorrectly, these violations increase, the mind is craving still called Career A- Lohans or go on the road to Arhat (Arhat direction).

(1) Th .: - Is He said that the author of such people rank Arhat to commit any offense as described above (XXIII 1)? He rejected, but why only limited to a single offense (sexual)?

3. MARKET CURRENT PROBLEMS OF EMPIRE(Issariyakamakarkatha)

Rate debate : A Bodhisattva goes to (a) hell, (b) being pregnant, (c) the refuge, (d) baptized with the other teachings of desire.

According to Note:  This concept of sect  Andhakas .

(1) Th .: - he said: Bodhisattva come in and be subjected to punishment in hell, hell ... modern era forest life motto hell?

If he rejected, how he can maintain his thesis that make?

Could he give me cite texts to prove this thesis?

(2) he can maintain that the bodhisattvas enter the mother's pregnancy as desired. Does he imply that the bodhisattva choose reborn in hell or animalzxy? Clairvoyance Bodhisattva reasonable? He declined. I ask again, He agreed. so there must have practiced bodhisattva as standard Four-sufficiency: Education, need, care, competence? He can not be a prayer invoked to prove the point.

(3) Moreover, he maintained that the Bodhisattva wishes to practice austerity. Is it that way, he said that Bodhisattvas are going back wrong views as: "The world is permanent, infinite world ...". "The soul and body alike, different". "As future existence after death", "No existence ..."? He may yet give me cite texts to prove this?

(4) Moreover, he maintains desired Bodhisattva refuge ceremony with another religion. So does this imply that the Bodhisattva has the views of religious leaders do not? Could he give me cite texts to prove this?

4. ISSUES OF CURRENT STATUS AUTHOR CENTER(Ragapatirupakadikatha)

Rate debate : There are not legal greed, hatred, ignorance and negativity, but that the current price of each method.

According to Note : This concept of sect  Andhakas.

(1) Th .: - Is He supposes the non-contact method, non-life, non-concept, a great pilot, astronaut, non-official, non-believers, non-necessary, non-concept, non-specified, non-bending, but there the author of each approach him?

(2) The same argument for the legal field, ignorance and misery.

5. LEGAL ISSUES uncertainty (Apurinipphanakatha)

Rate debate : Aggregates, Land, except suffering and uncertainty Rights . (Aparinipphana)

According to Note : This concept of sect  Uttarapathaka s and  Hetuvadins.

(1) Th .: - There must maintain that identity is not impermanent, is not compounded, there is relatively SNH forensic, legal standards are not corrupt, not the education law, is not to destroy or change the law? Is it true, or why not the reverse?

(2) Does he imply that only new suffering is the cause? He agreed to it? But is Exalted has declared that: Anything that's something impermanent is suffering? If this is so because the material is also impermanent. He could not maintain only the new format is determined.END=NAM MO CAKYA MOUNI BUDDHA.( 3 TIMES ).VIETNAMESE TRANSLATE ENGLISH BY=THICH CHAN TANH.THE MIND OF ENLIGHTENMENT.WORLD VIETNAMESE BUDDHIST ORDER=VIETNAMESE BUDDHIST NUN=GOLDEN LOTUS MONASTERY=AUSTRALIA,SYDNEY.28/10/2016.MHDT.