THE REMAINING IN  emptiness 

In  doing Elementary No  ( Central  3, No. 121;  Middle Agama , No. 190), Buddha confirmed  thanks to  reside  should not have  to dwell  a lot. His  teaching experience  to encourage you  bhikkhus  should  practice emptiness  feet a way it's not crazy . At any abode, what in his abode no, time to shop is not there. But what was actually there at the residence, the time to shop is actually there. In meditation witness  any evidence, what  evidence meditation  does not have, time to shop is not there, but what  meditation witness  had, time to shop is actually there.   

"For as castles  sample Loc  has no elephants, cows, horses, mares, no gold and silver, without women, men gathered," the time to contemplate things that are not. But there is something not right, is the  presence  of  us Increase  in  monasteries, time to contemplate  them Increase  really is there, telling clearer  idea  about villages but no  idea  about the people there. It was  the calm at  the feet of  the true nature  No, not  crazy .

Moving on one level,  monks  do if you want  to dwell  much in the  emptiness ,  monks  did not contemplate to the  idea  of the village, do meditation to the  idea of people, which often meditated on a  idea  homogeneous  on forest wilderness. That position is not consistent villages, who are not, but there is something not right, because in the forest, the forest should be real. He  insight  "The  sorrow caused by  the idea  of the village, so  the idea  of people have no  existence , but the  sorrow  caused by  the idea of  homogeneity of the true wilderness here." Something not present, he considered not present. What is present, he  considered  that there is truth. Practice so-called  practice of  "emptiness".

Continue to  add steps forward again,  monks  do if you want  to dwell  much in the  emptiness ,  monks  did not meditate on  the idea  of people, do not meditate on  the idea of  wilderness, which generally contemplate a  concept homogenized of land. If you find this flat ground as palms, place looks out  clear , then usually meditate. He said that: "The idea of people,  the idea  of wilderness is not, but there is something not right, that is  the idea of  homogeneity  of the soil. The  troubles  caused by  the idea of people, so  the idea  of wilderness can not  exist , but the  sorrow  caused by  the idea of  homogeneity  on the actual land here. " If there is not nothing, so that the he should not; if there is something else which, he saw the truth there. It was  the calm at  the feet of  the true nature  No, not  crazy .

Just like that,  pass  the  certification meditation  on  Immaterial world , he does not reflect on  the infinite Origin No  idea, the  land of boundless  ideas, the  origin is naught  idea, not contemplating on  the idea  of  Africa heresies non-perception, and often failure  net recite  most of  formless  concentration  (this means that your stock is  concentration  by using an object that no minister should be called the "formless concentration").

You  monks  shop  formless  concentration  belong  compounded , created by the mind. If capital is the office, which is the basis of investment, time not  loving touch it, not expecting it, do not  dwell  on it. Due to such shop, his mind  freed  from  illicit sex ,  illegal possession , and  ignorance . He  insight : "The  sorrow conditioned  illegal sex , conditioned by  organic contraband , conditioned by  ignorance  are not present here. Here, there is only  sorrow  by  six entering (eyes, ears, nose, tongue, body , standard) network affinity, affinity with this body. " He  insight : "This perceiving no  illicit sex , no  organic contraband , no  ignorance . And this is not only a right, ie the  six imported  network affinity, affinity with this body." "And what is not to be here, see what he does is not here. But for the rest here, he knows what is here is real. This  Ananda , this one for for he is so, it has, not  crazy , is  performed  entirely  pure , and  the ultimate  realization of emptiness  ".

According to the above passages, for where  monks  practice ,  depending on the residence, or in the village, or in the forest, or convent crowded, or practicing  alone , what was not there at the abode, the  monks  are consistent not. And what was in residence there, the shop is actually there. Also in  meditation evidence  , such as  attained  nirvana  liberation , when he  insight  are the  cankers  is no, because were the exception, but because also the  friendly  medical opinion, the bodies  of six entering coast network, the body was still real. The body has, when there are  troubles  caused by his body, should have the body, the time has aged, sick, has died. But because you have  been freed , so there is no  sorrow suffering cerebral superiority, oil body disease, with elderly, have died.

The following passages are repeated up to eight times, after each taste  monks  a step forward on the roadmap  Meditation : "And what is not to be here, see what he does is not here. but for the rest here, he knows what is here is real. this  Ananda , this one for he is so, it has, not  crazy , is  done  completely  pure , and  the ultimate  realization of  emptiness ". This passage raised two opposite points, a surface  emptiness  is not  present , but the other surface  still something left in it because it should not be  dismissed . Thus,  emptiness  is defined as  non-organic  , but organic, which confirmed negative.

It is difficult to understand in the passage  meaning  of the phrase "the rest (avasista)",  because  the usual  emptiness  is  seen as  non-existence , there is  character  Negative. In contrast , say, to "the rest" that affirms the existence of something. Does  "the other" is a really useful  finality  has not been  rejected , even when negative process  reaches  the final level? For example,  the case  can not be a negative  event  that we're negative. It was an immediate confirmation amid negative, and is a really useful because it is  found  in the negative.

Philosophy  Madhyamikas  of  emptiness  no mention  of Elementary Not this. Remarks  Great place  his degree  Nagarjuna  comes reads  stance Madhyamikas on  issues  Huu Chan Khong Yew  of  Prajna  as follows: "In the  Prajnaparamita , sometimes  distinguish  these  measures are not , which is part shortsighted ; sometimes say the legal  world  is  nirvana , which is the dark. all the  material are Dharma "(Vol 72). Even with the vacuum  negative everyone always conjoined approach confirmed the  outstanding property  is the legal  world. Vacuum  and  wonderful friendship  never  separated from  each other, and this can be understood as a homogeneous  non-organic  and organic, negative and positive, and the  rehabilitation of  the property from the  non-organic . We can tell that the  outstanding property  is  the realm of  "rest" looked under  Prajna wisdom as told in the  Diamond Sutra : "All measures are  Buddhism . Hey Tu Bodhi! Saying all that immediate measures are not all legal, all legal-called "[ Necessary measures  during market  Dharma . Tu Bodhi! Language Department  legal necessarily  false  -pilot  necessarily legal  incidents marketing  list  legal necessarily ].

For cardboard  Yoga  of  Asanga  was later  Vasubandhu  reformed into  sectarianism  Duy form  the opposite,  trading Elementary Not  that  documents essential to  overs  standpoint  Middle  of cardboard. It should be known that this tone  is not accepted  in  theory  everyone  is able to  have  existed , since  conception  nothing but  the impact  of the mind, and  not accept  in  theory nothing  exists , because  asserting  that the form of  existence . Episode  Middle Border Measures Comments  (Madhyanta-vibhaga) in which he  Asanga presents a very  precise  philosophy His teachings on  the path  between the two arguments and advocates organic  no matter , beginning with the two posts proceedings clarify  the meaning  of  emptiness  and  centrally directed  as follows:

abhutaparikalpo 'sti, dvayam vidyate Tatra na  
atra Śūnyatā vidyate tv, tasyam api sa vidyate - (I.1)

Napi casunyam tasmat na sarvam vidhiyate sunyam  
asattvat sattvad sattvac ca, ca sa Madhyama pratipac - (I.2)

Services are:

Falsehoods distinction  exists ; ( Is minister ) duality without which  
, however ,  emptiness  in there, and the first law ( falsehoods distinction ) also in the last method ( emptiness ). - (I.1)

Therefore to say that all things are not no such measures have to  gallop 
at the property because, as in the  non-organic , and again by at the property. And that is the  Middle Way . - (I.2)

Procedure I.1 opening all right to say 'falsehoods distinguish' refers to knowledge (Vijnana). He  Asanga  asserting the  existence  of  falsehoods distinction . Say so means  confirming  the presence of the subject  distinguishes falsehoods . All  phenomena  empirical object is actually  perceived  by a subject  falsehoods perceive that  distinction  is part ,  Minister section . When  interpreting  this verse he  Vasubandhu  only shows one side, with the subject asserting  falsehoods  is reinforced to counter the policy had nothing  exists , and on the other, are the legal theory on all  falsehoods  is reinforced to counter undertakings all  the might have  existed .

Sentence  Next  "( is minister ) duality (dvaya) without which" means that the  distinction falsehoods , duality  absolutely  no  substance  given in  terms of  the base . Ie self two parts  is minister without spending is down is legal, but every  mortal  confusion  based on component is  approved for the fall,  based on the general section  for the legal observance. This is just one way of competition for artificial  distinction falsehoods , but if he leaves two sections  is general  time is nothing called self, is legal. Thus,  down approach  based on  two parts  is minister  of  internal knowledge  that  the simulator  is  illusory , not having anyone  mistaken  to have.

The negative  essence  of the  minister is  duality is repeated in the third sentence of article I.1 proceedings under  the form  of emptiness : "Emptiness in there," ie in  distinguishing falsehoods . Such means  falsehoods distinction  is negative, meaning  falsehoods distinction  is not, the same attention to him  Nagarjuna : "The law as  Origination , should I say is not". Last sentence recite all  Middle Border Measures comment  I.1, "the first law ( falsehoods distinction ) in legal end ( emptiness )", want to say that  falsehoods distinction is  revived , as well as all proceedings  Mādhyamika  XXIV .18: "the law as  origination , should I say is not, as  assumed identity , and also the Middle Way" comes to  Assume the list  is taken by the  origination  is  for work  again after being negative.

He  Vasubandhu  commentary  I.1 all proceedings as follows: "So (in all this action) characteristics of  emptiness  are  notes  in a way not  crazy (ie  true ) like this: 'It is  seen as the truth  is when this is  absent  in the other, the other one is not, and moreover, it is known  as the truth  is when something left here, see that's the truth here '. "

No  can not  recognize  a  speech  identical  brought together when  comparing text  commentary  with paragraph is repeated eight times in the  Economic Sub Not  mentioned in the previous section. Does  he  Vasubandhu wanted to  invoke economic Elementary No  evidence to determine  the views  of his  former wife about the  emptiness  of the Middle Border Measures comment?

I.2 all proceedings  subsequent  've  y  is  stated  in article I.1 proceedings which asserted that: "Everybody is not no such measures have to gallop" and gives  reason  to  explain  in the statement  next , "because at the property, as in the  non-organic , and again by at the property." According to him  Vasubandhuglossary , the first sentence "Because in the organic" means "by now  falsehoods distinction  exists" and this sentence  cited  for the proposition that "there is not". The second sentence "by the non-existence in the" means "by now the duality does not exist" and this sentence  cited  for the proposition that "not gallop". Third sentence "at the property again by the" means "by at  emptiness  in  falsehoods distinguish  and  differentiate falsehoods  in emptiness" and this sentence  cited for the proposition that "there is not".

Sentence  ends  all litigation I.2, "which is the Middle Way", suggesting he  Asanga  wrote  Middle Border Measures comment  to  interpretation  theory of  the Middle Way  and use the  emptiness  of  falsehoods distinction  as  examples . It should  be noted  that Mr.  Asanga  describes  Middle  I.1-2 either recite all of the  Middle Border Measures argument right in the way  Bodhisattva Nagarjuna described  the Middle Way  in all proceedings XXIV.18 of  Madhyamarg . At first glance, we see the difference is in the  Middle customary , the starting point is  calculated interdependent , and the  consciousness-only  previous time  out talking  to  distinguish falsehoods . Central shop concepts using  abstract  as  predestined  (pratitya) is starting (utpatti),  operation  (gamana), ... and metaphysical concepts like self (Atman),  nature  (svabhava),  etc.  ... However,  Duy form  concepts used  specifically  more,  contact  to the  method of cultivation , and  familiar  with  life  daily, as the mind (citta), knowledge (Vijnana), and  falsehoods distinction  ( abhutaparikalpa). Although  falsehoods distinction  is a concept  related  intimately  to the  coast station scene  of the  only consistent , but  in fact ,  falsehoods distinction  is knowledge and knowledge is  interdependent , one of all  forensic  tha launch,  existing  by the coast, rather than something real outside any legal private. Therefore a  distinction falsehoods  no different  y launch tha calculated . Since  he began the neighbor  means origination calculated  so the  formula Duy  also  seen as  taking  calculated interdependence  as the starting point of  describing  the process  of practice  to achieve a  Middle Way  as side  Madhyamikas .

Moreover, all proceedings  Middle Border Measures comment  I.1  explained  very fully the process  dialectically  lead to  qualitative  emptiness  leaning on the two  views ,  non-organic  (division two) and organic ( emptiness ). For  yogis  at  the initial , start talking to the  emptiness  of  falsehoods distinction  is  natural  and logical . Therefore,  emptiness  is established by negative "is assigned two generals." Both actors and audience  perceptions  are negative. Say so means negative whole  world . Whole  world  is not, in accordance with the premise "Necessary measures No" of  Madhyamikas  has  said . Emptiness  here not only  purely  negative. It's  super-Vietnam  friendship and all the  non-organic . So the first two verses recite all  Mādhyamika  XXII.11 said: "No rules  impossibility theory ;  Africa is not  impossible theory". Ie: can not speak to  confirm  what is not as well as the  non-no . Last litigation Middle Border Measures comment  I.2  explain  this with more  detail  than. All proceedings  confirmed  right at the start, "all things are not no such measures have to gallop", and then specify  the cause based on three  reasons : the organic, the  non-organic , and organic. Two  reasons  first, "because in the native" and "non-organic by at the" opposite should be considered on the same level and  considered  in the order  praised  the affirmation and negation. Reason  third, "because at the property again", must be understood on a level  super Vietnam  two  reasons  first. Therefore, the third time it comes to property does not  fellow  with organic spelled out in  the reasons  first. This time, the property contains  two meanings . One,  emptiness  exists  in  distinguishing falsehoods . Two,  falsehoods distinction  exists  in  emptiness . Was the  emptiness  of the negative characteristics and  non-organic . Now it comes to the existence of the  emptiness  of course,  ridiculous  and foul self  contradictory . He  Thanh Bien  (Bhavaviveka) of  Madhyamakas  slammed  this policy vehemently sent  Duy formula . This sect but  knew  it but did not  hesitate to  define  emptiness  as  simultaneously  "no and no no"  as  all litigation  Middle Border Measures comment  I.13 following:

dvayabhavo hy sunyasya abhavasya bhavah laksanam

Translated as: Special Minister of  emptiness  is no duality (ie not), and there is no duality (ie  no not ).

Phai  Duy formula  usually  based on the  theory of  nature tam  tam indefinite nature  to  clarify  the concept of organic and  non-organic . Beijing League intimate  recounted  Buddha  taught  Bodhisattvas  win means  born of three  indefinite nature : "Wins mean birth, be  aware  that  the Tathagata  bases three  indefinite nature  following that  confidential reviews  say the  whole approach  is not. He is minister  indefinite nature , born  indefinite nature ,  meaning victory indefinite nature ".

Minister  indefinite nature  is  variable mortgage successor  of the legal property. Why? Because  variable mortgage accounting basis  set  based on the  famous general , the  generals  is  the symbol of the heart, but actually no  properties exist  so-called Minister  indefinite nature . Born  indefinite nature  is  calculated y tha launch  of France. Why? Because due to  causes and conditions  of the new law arises, which  predestined  the time were so interested, in itself no  character separate, so-called birth  indefinite nature . Win means  indefinite nature  there are two. One is the  calculated y tha start , because the student is exercised by  indefinite nature  that say  indefinite nature  and  properties y launch tha  audience is not  contemplating  hanging on to that which is the  purity  of mind so  y launch tha calculation  is not  won imperialism  ie  base . So  he began the neighbor called the  win means indefinite nature . The two are  members counted honestly, because Minister  selflessness  of all things  the law  is  winning imperialism  ie  the base  and  the staff  led by General  selflessness  manifest , that is thanks to the  pure mind  are included, in addition to it's mind no  nature  should  honestly calculated member  called  victory means  indefinite nature .

As above, can understand the word no in three ways. (1) Because the show is due to  approve the next turn , the  changing  nature  of the subject knowledge  to distinguish  objects and  differentiate , so  the reality  that knowledge is not seeing  reality  in itself but merely  a generation  competition artificial world of two parts  is minister  did. So  next variable mortgage calculation basis  'no' because it is subject to negative  rejected . Therefore, does not mean  non-existence , is not.

(2) For  calculation y launch tha  interdependence is the birth of  thousands of property  so can see by  observing  differentiated  set of elements form the foundation coast  clinics  of  awareness  (pratisedhyavastu; pratisedha-visaya) . Show start  conditioned  but there is a way but there is  relatively . So  began the medical excuse  'no' because it is "the other" after the negative  variable mortgage plan  properties and "the rest" that is not. Negative audiences (pratisedhya) here is the  minister is  duality. Therefore, does not mean lack of  mortgage variable design  platform features where  clinics  of  awareness and "the rest" is not there.

(3)  Member honestly calculated  as the  manifestation  of the  selfless approach ie  emptiness , ie  Legs like , ie  the truth  of reality . But can not see the  participants into  truth  if not  see the  y tha  launch, like  the case of  unknown  character  impermanence  of  things  , if not  seen to know the law  of impermanence . The  absence  of  variable mortgage plan  properties where  y tha began the work  that appears intelligent  honest member properties , objects  in the morning  due to  the wisdom of pure  awareness . So  honestly calculated members  , also known as  pure grace basis , because that object hanging on a clean piece of  negativity  ultimate fulfillment  of enlightenment . So  the staff really 'no' because it is the  truth as  minister of  things . Therefore, not the  emptiness , is  the goal  of training the mind and  deployment  of insight  in the morning  super-Vietnam  world , kind of  insight especially  tri willow  Minister Chan  reality .

Through  contact  with three  very nature ,  Duy formula  based on  three qualities,  variable mortgage plan ,  y tha  launch, and  member of  truth, to  notes three ways  existence of the law. Nature means, but each character has every way:  the next turn  is expected organic, meaning that there is a  mistake ; y tha the  author property , means a  relative ; and  the staff  is  very useful , ie have an authentic way. Accordingly, the  variable mortgage plan  properties  corresponding with the  non-organic  and  calculated y launch tha  corresponds  to the property. The organic  contact  with  y tha  launch absence  variable mortgage plan  is "the other" is mentioned in the Economic Sub No . Thus,  emptiness  means the lack of something here and claiming to be the rest here.

How to  explain the  emptiness  so are  found  in all proceedings starting Friday Products:  Established  emptiness , in  Show Puritans positive conclusion , the translation of the Chinese character set € ryadesana-vikhyapana also by Mr.  Asanga  wrote.

Disadvantages u try  very useful 
Go try residual  ownership 
Depending  II strains  ethical 
theory  No minister  incomparable .

Translation is: If something's not here, but with the rest here, the  agreement under  reasonable  sensitive strains  which  explains  emptiness  incomparable.

Part Luin the  prose  interpretation  of  sensitive strains  (1) two generals down, and goodness falls  down approach , no; but (2) the two generals  selflessness , kindness  selflessness  and  selfless approach  is real. According to the  sensitive strains ,  emptiness  is not two, not a minister down there for two  non-organic , and not because the two generals not  selfless  existence . Two generals  selflessness  is "the rest" after the two generals were negative ego. This  proves he  Asanga  has relied on the  experience Elementary Not  to  preach  emptiness.

He also  applied  for  sensitive strains  to  interpretation  Diamond Sutra Prajna Paramita  in his collection Karikasaptati comment. Determinant "negates the existence and non-existence confirms the" very  convenient  when used for the  interpretation meaning  the full sentence  conflict , "ie, non, urban identity" (ie not, tentatively called), in  Diamond Sutra .

Concerning  economic Elementary No  and definition  emptiness  under  Vijnaptivada  is cited in the following paragraphs  of Lankavatara  (DT Suzuki translated the English version).

"What is tough is not tough? What nature this has that the other does not, the lack of identity that Belgium was not called.  For example , the  Form Loc Tu  no horse elephant goat buffalo v .. v .. and hoped to bring this home. it was not meant them no  Bhikkhu  here. the house is, with  self-generals house,  monks  are  monks , have  self Minister  monks . Elephant buffalo horse goat are in the right their place but not in another place already. Thus, every object is  self Minister  differences for other materials,  self minister  that no differences in other organisms. the absence of Belgium was not he called. Dai Hui! There are seven things that do not. that's not what Belgium was not very rough, he must  rid ourselves of . "

Buddha  did not say to seven minutes in the previous paragraph:

"Great Hue! There is a place  next turn  falsehoods  (parikalpita). Dai Hue! Because  attachment  design variables  falsehoods  should new  preachers  not (sunyata),  the unborn  (anutpada), not two (advaya),  departed minister  himself nature  (nihsvabhava). Combs said, there are seven things that do not (sunyata):  Minister not  (laksana-sunyata),  nature nature  not (bhavasvabhava-sunyata),  shall not  (pracarita-sunyata),  countless acts  not (apracarita-sunyata) ,  legal necessarily  separatist discourse theory does not (sarvadharma-nirabhilapya-sunyata),  First means  holy place  not great  (aryajnana-sunyata), Belgium was not (itaretara-sunyata). "

Saturday NOs, Belgium was not, was the  emptiness  mentioned in the  Economic Sub No . Thus, in contrast to  the views  of his  Vasubandhu  that  emptiness  in the  Economic Sub not  "be  notes  a crazy manner,"  Lankavatara of  Belgium was not put on the kind of "not very rough," and advised to  rid ourselves .

It should  be noted  in all proceedings  Middle Border Measures comment  I.1, in the sentence "( is minister ) duality without which (in  falsehoods distinction )", both, subject and object  perception , were negative. Later sent  Duy formula  but  inheritance  system  Yoga  of  Asanga  but negative  world  outside (objects  perceived ) said no, and  consciousness  (subjectivity  awareness ) within the time confirmed flag.

As  stated above, both  Madhyamikas  and  Yoga  are used  dialectical  approach  to justice  navigation  Middle . However ,  the language  of  Yoga  has little difference with the wording of  the Middle comment . For example, near the end of all legal sentences  Middle Border Measures comment  I.2 three times used the word 'because in' to set out very  clearly  the basis of  the dialectical  process of translation of  legal goods  on  aspects  of  language : "By in the property, because in the  non-organic , and again by at the property. "

Looking in a general way the surface, the method developed  Middle  of the two sides,  China shop  and  Yoga , dissimilar. In addition , the concept of  emptiness of  Yoga  also carries many  characteristics  Madhyamikas . If  researchers  keen than the same time  demonstration  service  dialectical  sides of heterogeneous real or not? On the other hand, although the same title is  emptiness , the true each party has  assigned to the  emptiness, a  sense  separately? It certainly  can be said to be the beginning of the translation process  chemistry methods  of  Madhyamikas  starting  interdependence  that  Yoga  starts from the  distinction falsehoods . Regarding the definition  of emptiness ,  Yoga  is not only useful but negates the  same time  also confirmed "the existence of non-existence". In addition , although both  schools of thought  are taken  of the General Products Prajna  as the basis  of thought , but  Yoga  also stand on  the stance  of the  Economic Sub Not  to  notes  emptiness .

So is there a difference in  the concept  of emptiness . Because  why  what born  opinion  heterosexual co? Maybe because were based on  classics  of different reasonable? Or because the policy  sects  are not the same individual? Or being able to  adapt  to  the times  that the full  doctrine  of emptiness  , of course happen?

On  fact ,  Madhyamarg  his  Nagarjuna  important too fond of  dialectical negation so often  misunderstood  as advocated  nihilistic  conclusion. Maybe  so , but sex  Yoga  are  reacted  complementary  ideological  emptiness  of  Madhyamaka . Main thanks to  super Vietnam  synthetic  opposition , negative and positive,  non-organic  and organic, that  emptiness  is  seen as a basic tenet of the  ideology  of Mahayana . Can only  be based on the direct synthesis shop  especially  of  Mahayana  characteristics penetrating new  contradictions  of the system, but most  of emptiness , a new  communication of  the  combined falsehoods distinction  with  emptiness , a new  interpretation  of the famous  paradox  confusing the  Mahayana  as "Samsara is nirvana" or "Defilement is Bodhi."

Unlike  China shop  and  Yoga  was  y themselves  from  being legal predestined,  falsehoods  being legal  to comment on the  super Vietnam  synthesis  opposition  of  emptiness , of Thang Man,  Lankāvatāra , comment  Run credit , ...  y every  word  count Tathagata organ  which  notes  that  emptiness  is "no and no no." First  need to  explain  nouns  Tathagata organs . One piece  Diamond Sutra , a Sanskrit, refers to the word  synonymous with  word  Tathagata : "Hey Tu Bodhi!  Tathagata  is from  means  such as legs , the law  regardless of birth , legal  cessation , with measures  absolute  born not  start ". In Chinese, the same  meaning  , but just a very brief statement: "As a hybrid author, ie  dharmas  as meaning", translated as:  Tathagata  news of the legal meaning. So  Tathagata means  such as legs . Legs like  that  word often used  to  describe  the reality finality  beyond  identification  and definition. In the  mean  contact  Tathagata and  Chan as  the "Like" means in terms of  perception  as "legs  really not crazy" and in terms of  being  the "existence  of currencies  permanent unchanging".

How are organs of the Tathagata? Buddhahood arguments  raised three means of "organs":

(1) Base Tibetan news photography, photography is what you gather again, what has been  maintained . For example  specific  about the kind of stuff, it's the yolk of the egg, the embryo in  the womb , the seed to engender  Tathagata  later. In this sense, all  beings  are  the Tathagata organs . But  sentient  nature is infectious, but  Tathagata  essence of  purity . So  Tathagata organ  composed of two  factors  conflict , infected and continence. To  resolve  the issue  contradicts this  Lankāvatāra  out  concept  switch y  (asrayaparavrtti). The only formula  had  built eight official transition into four very complete site based on the principle of  conditionality . Beijing Wins Man said: "Tri's  Tathagata organ  is the mind  Tathagata  of emptiness". So  emptiness  is fundamental to the  health transfer  it.

(2) ie hidden Tibetan-being, that is covered,  concealed . But it is something to be  concealed  or the coverage? If talking is being  concealed  the  reason  is  because  although still  a permanent  existence  in the sense that "never came and never left," but  ordinary  totally  unaware of his presence. Item  Two redundant  ( Sravakas  and  Pratyekabuddha ) does not know and does not believe there is. Customers  Bodhisattva , depending  qualified  enlightenment that many believe  or trust  less. To every  local superior  Bodhisattvas  new  fully believe they are. Here, the message means, though not seen, but because Buddha said and listened to by into  the shop , but police believe her.

Buddhahood comment  explaining  the meaning 'the hidden' because the  Tathagata  is not to hide itself says is "visceral". This business win Man called "True happiness No hidden meaning," which is  explained  in Bao Thang Man fart just because he  Cat Tibetan  composer: "France  falsehoods  not  implemented ownership; call it the No (sunyata). The  meaning  to understand whether what he is saying is not meant (artha). the not  cover  loss of  Buddhahood , should say is宠true happiness ". Because no means ie  no character  should "not meaning to being True" translates as:  True  nature is  not nature  obscures .

No nature  ie  Tathagata  nature, a word can be used to indicate the essence of  existence . Total  reassembled , "Tathagata organ" is  rational  interdependence , is  not nature , is  the rule  of law therefore  exists  and is  perceived . This is mentioned in two articles litigation  Middle comment  below.

All proceedings  Mādhyamika  XXII.16:

Tathagata  possesses  properties  
That  appears so  calculated  
Tathagata  very useful  features  
The world  herons  asexual .

Translation is: Anything is  nature  of  Tathagata  is the  nature  of  the worldis. Tathagata  has no  nature  to  the world  this is no  self . All proceedings  Mādhyamika  XXIV.14:

Certainly  does not organic  means trying  
Necessary measures  accomplish the  
downside  very not  mean fake  
Necessarily  failed switch.

Services are: All thanks be to  adapt  to the  emptiness . If you do not have the  sense  that the measures are not of all such forms.

Since  the Tathagata organ  is  reason  should always hidden. And because of the  reason  of  existence  it  permanent  existence . Thus,  the Tathagata  nature is  primordial purity ,  eternal  existence  even  of currencies , in all  existence , but since time without beginning  to now  be  disturbing  contaminated  obscures hidden can not  revealing  so  beings  do not see .

(3) Organ instant photographic performance. Meaning  this  status  certifications , ie  Supreme Bodhi  or Buddha. Beijing Wins Man said: "Tathagata organ which does not leave outside minister  compounded .  Tathagata organs  which  often head , not destroyed.  That is why  the Tathagata organ  is what  maintains , is the setting". In this sense, the word "organ" in Sanskrit  literally  as "the womb". Thus,  the Tathagata organ  is the seat of the shifting y  pure legal  merit  wisdom  and also the seat of the legal medical shifting  mortal  contamination  non-  wisdom . Even the  Tathagata , monks and  Buddhist Venerable  conceived  in  love and compassion  countless of him all  merit  boundless  and qualities  super Vietnam of the  Tathagata , and all  compounded  contamination  falsehoods  perversion of  beings . When  beings  do  realize  is  Tathagata  nature,  Buddha nature , or  the form of Buddha  permanent  place of  nature  his then  living beings he called "death Tathagata feet".

Vevan problem "and not any non",  Thang Man Lady  presents "O Exalted!  Tathagata organ  is no place where the  Tathagata . ... Revered sir! No place two of the  Tathagata organ . Bach World Ton!  not Tathagata organs  are all  afflictions of organs , or leave, or escape, or differences. Bach Exalted!  do not Half organ is  Dharma  excess  of sand of the Ganges , do not leave, do not break, no allergic particularly,  any investment recommendations . "

Intellectual  awareness  Tathagata organs  called  organ Tathagata  position ( stock position ). Tri was of  absolute  separation from  serving generals , so to say is not located. Can also  explain  that no place is conditioned on  Tathagata organ which arises where  perception  No nature  of the  Tathagata  (substrate base), only the new Buddhist  insight , can  experience . On the one hand, stand on  legal necessarily  emptiness  of  beings  that speak of place  Prajna  is  Tathagata visceral  place. On the other hand,  beings  but inherent to this position, but never show forth a great advantage, must wait until the  spiritual advancement achievements ,  fullness  detected, the position of prime None  Tathagata . Ie  stock position  due to the acquisition of sole witness. So says  Tathagata organ  is located  Tathagata  not talk about location ie where  most as  called  Tathagata organs  not located.

No location of  Tathagata organ  has two. One is  not Tathagata organs . This is  based on the  characteristics of the  Tathagata organs  but were  disturbing unclean  binding but not  so  that fused with  negativity . Since  the Tathagata organs depart, escape, different from all  negativity  , so say  the Tathagata organ is not. Can also  explain  that  not Tathagata organ  is  disturbing organs , because themselves of  negativity  which  falsehoods ,  not really .

Secondly  Real not Tathagata organ . No not  because of self-  organ Tathagatahas all the legal estate incredible  merit  boundless  and qualities  super Vietnamese  Buddha. Any non Tathagata organ  is  the form of Buddha , like  Thang Man Lady  said: "venerable sir! Do  achievements  Dharma  estate incredible  excess  of sand of the Ganges , which is not glass, not escape, not heresy, because How to say is  Dharmakaya Tathagata . Thus, transparency  Bhagavan ,  Tathagata Dharma body  does not leave  negativity organ , so called  Tathagata  organ ".

Bring  comparative  perspective  "and not any non" of the Middle Border Measures and win Man of the time saw two points worth mentioning.

(1) In the Thang Man,  Tathagata organ  just does not fit  any no . But only  organ afflictions  ( No Tathagata organ ) is able to be self-negation, but the  Tathagata organs  ( visceral Any non Tathagata ) has not been deducted control. Obstacles either by  habits , customs, and mores cancer molded composite  organ afflictions, so  must  cultivate paragraph  afflictions  until  the  ultimate clean section. And  Dharmakaya Tathagata  's immediate self  Tathagata organ  is composed of full  gathering force ,  from countless Lt ,  plus bowl estate law , ..., which includes all  the merits  boundless  and qualities  super Vietnam  's  Tathagata  so impossible is not.

Thus, in the  case  when it comes to "no and no no", the subject of "no" is  disturbing  and the subject of "no no" is  merit  boundless  and qualities  super Vietnam . In contrast, in the  Middle Border Measures conclusion , "emptiness in  falsehoods distinguish  and  differentiate falsehoods  in emptiness". Means that the  minister is  duality, of itself  distinguishes falsehoods , be  dismissed . Thus  emptiness  is not. But through purification by  emptiness  falsehoods distinction is  revival  under a  form  new, forming the 'no no' in the  emptiness . And the "no no" never leave  emptiness . So it can be said or  emptiness  or  falsehoods distinguish  the subject of the "no" and "no no". It was a dual structure is not possible in  the Tathagata organ , because of which,  the Tathagata  Dharma body is  permanent  existence  can not merge with  organ afflictions  including  the  compounded  impermanence .

(2)  The meaning  of the phrase "the other" can only be  applied  in the Middle Border Measures or in  economic Elementary No . In  doing Elementary Not  the other  final  was the  friendly  medical opinion, the bodies  of six entering  coast network. In the  Middle Border Measures argument , the other is a  distinction falsehoods , that  icon  the  world  phenomena  illusory . Both texts elicit  opinions are not easily cleaned piece  ultimately  ignorance  negativity , because always left something impossible but clean. Conversely, economic Thang Man seems  optimistic over. About  tu paragraph  negativity , this trade show presentation  witnessed  gnosis  demands from life  reality  must constantly  cultivate  to  gradually  clean except the  infection before  subtle  hidden in  the mind . The  cessation  or place obstacles such as subtraction. So  how to get rid of here in a translation process  chemistry methods  as in  the case of  the Middle Border Measures comment .

Generally speaking the  meditator  insight  "what is left" at the moment of  enlightenment . When  achievements  medical transfer ,  transfer knowledge  into place, the witness knew  Tathagata organ  is "the rest". Concept  so  it is notappropriate  at all with the theory  Tathagata organs  according to this theory  organ Tathagata  constant  existence , neither coming nor going, with the  original, should not be the other.

Later, comment  Mahayana  followers departure  also comes to  the Tathagata organs . According to this argument,  can the Great  excess  interest news  beings covers all the  tangible worldliness  and  outflows ,  the earth  and  the Earth . This center has two generals:  Legs like  and  Birth kill . Mental  birth and death ie  formula A leather back , a comment said: "Since  the Tathagata organ  which centered  birth and death . That is Chon ( not born  destroy) Hope ( birth and death ) harmony, not the other one is not called  formula A the skin . this consciousness captured the all the legal and  emerged  all legal. this Soul has  two meanings , enlightenment ( wisdom ) and  Suddenly  (love). " Enlightenment is the Buddha Nature availability of  beings . Buddha nature where  beings  called the  Tathagata organ , even where  the Buddha  called "French  equality body  of the Tathagata". A re-skin formula  is  y tha  launch ie  based on  other measures that arise. Members of  the new truth is  Truth like ,  the nature  of all things legal, is  formless ,  shuns  all things minister, that is  the essence  (svabhava). The only form of concrete  policy nature (svabhava) of the measures  totally  different from (laksana) thereof. Like  Chan as  not  contact  anything to Minister of Justice. Legs like  never  decorations set  or  affect  the  life  reality . As discontinued foot course , not  grace that boot, and do not create legal effects. He  Asanga  little  attention  to theories  such as legs , because he advocates that once formed the principle of "The pure hybrid" the impossible from the principle that there is  a reality  "Real purity".

According  Lankāvatāra ,  Buddha  preached  Tathagata organ  is intended to fool out of  fear  at the mention of the theory  of selflessness . But  the Buddha described  it as an  entity  ultimate , eternal,  permanent , non-  decay  should give rise to the misconception that he taught the same thing said in the ego  system  philosophy . Buddha  insisted Tathagata organs  such co ego  pagan. Purpose  theory  Tathagata organ  is made of people  of self  awakening , "leave  that idea  down is not true, in  the realm of  liberation triangle subjects  (no,  formless ,  very willingly ),  hopefully  soon be  supreme  enlightenment class . "

Thus, on the way leading to lead the  realization  of emptiness , presentations  Tathagata organ  is not  an end  but a  means of teaching  is  necessary  at halfway stage  of practice . Once the  communication and  application  efficiency and must  leave  it immediately. 

"Tathagata deep Museum  
with seven general formula Which  
two things  life photography  birth  
surely wise man  shuns .  
As the mirror reflected the object  
gas Tap  without beginning  decorations  
The  lifelike  observe 
all of the sound.  
As stupid  that only moon  
View hands did not see the moon  
the  attached  letter 
shows us the true example.  
the mind is the piano or sing gioi0nhu  
Five friends wake as  
delusions  them to the theater. "END=NAM MO CAKYA MOUNI BUDDHA.( 3 TIMES ).VIETNAMESE TRANSLATE ENGLISH BY=THICH CHAN TANH.THE MIND OF ENLIGHTENMENT.VIETNAMESE BUDDHIST NUN=GOLDEN LOTUS MONASTERY=AUSTRALIA,SYDNEY.27/2/2017.